The homework-gate controversy – the two sides of a coin!


The homework-gate controversy that has engulfed the Australian cricket has drawn the ire of the critics, while the others are set about defending the abrupt removal of the players from the team.

Shane Watson victim of homework-gate controversy
Shane Watson – victim of homework-gate controversy

Questions are being raised against the Arthur’s integrity as a coach and the puppy, who is ‘supposedly’ incapable of keeping his players behind the line.

Amidst all these unnecessary brouhaha, the question that needs answering is “whether the players deserved such harsh treatment for a silly theological process. The blatant answer would be in the negative, but that is how Australians operate, both on and off the field. They are completely professional and extremely passionate on what they do.

Sample this : The world T20 2009 saw Australia being ousted in the preliminary rounds. Their arsenal was severely depleted with the retirements of Adam Gilchrist and Mathew Hayden and yet they saw fit to drop Symonds owing to indiscipline. Australians are extremely proud about their cricketing acumen and their former grandeur.

The Australian think-tank:

Mitchell Johnson, victim of homework-gate controversy
homework-gate controversy

“We were particularly aware of where we were as a team and how we were going to get back. I asked the players at the end of the game to give me an individual presentation. I wanted three points from each of them technically, mentally and team as to how we were going to get back over the next couple of games, how we were going to get ourselves back into the series. Unfortunately four players didn’t comply with that. We pride ourselves on attitude. We have given the players a huge amount of latitude to get culture and attitude right,” – Mickey Arthur, coach, Australian cricket team.

Having been at the top of the table for the major part of the last decade, they are visibly facing a torrid time swallowing the bitter pill of climbing down the ladder. The team that once boasted of world-beaters tag remains a mirage of its former glory, unable to replicate its success story of the past.

Obviously, Mickey Arthur would be having a tough time in his endeavour to put the Australian team back on the board. The further losses of Ricky Ponting and Michael Hussey have pegged them quite heavily and the humiliation in India isn’t lifting any moods back in Australia. As the coach, he bears the responsibility to Cricket Australia and its fans. Therefore it isn’t hard to discern his predicament. A whitewash here would put his career in jeopardy.

The mindset of the players : Too harsh a punishment for the homework-gate controversy

homework-gate controversy
Usman Khawaja, a victim of homework-gate scandal

“Any time you are suspended from a Test match, unless you have done something unbelievably wrong and obviously everyone knows what those rules are – I think it is very harsh. In the end I have got to live with it. That is the decision they have made and at this point in time I am at a stage where I have to weigh up my future with what I want to do with my cricket in general.” – Shane Watson


On the other hand, let us spare thought for the situation of the suspended players. Shane Watson isn’t exactly a youngster and to be frank, he understands his place and responsibilities in the team. As a vice-captain, it would have been humiliating for him to be put under the scanner.

homework-gate controversy
homework-gate controversy

For the major part of his stop-start yet brilliant career, Watson was shunt from one side to the other. Injuries, form fluctuations and a certain other factors that included the might of the Australian team that kept him out of action. It was a struggle and yet he has managed to keep himself afloat. It is a huge achievement considering the facts presented, not to mention his single-handed effort that led Australia into the semi finals of the T20 world cup, 2012.

The others players (Usman Khawaja, Mitchell Johnson and James Pattinson) involved in this homework-gate controversy are extremely professional as well and with the kind of the competition that they are facing in the domestic circuit, it isn’t difficult to attest the fact that they are indeed deserving of their place in their side. Having seen club cricket, I have come to understand that a major part of the cricketers love to operate in their unique manner. Be it their fitness routines, or the type of drills that they undergo every day; it is certainly diverse for each player. To ask them to fill a form would absolutely sound ridiculous to their routines, not to mention their egos.

Homework-Gate Controversy : the bottom line

Though the Australian management saw fit to ban these players, they simply do not have a point to prove. Ultimately they are branded as the villain. Instead, they could be a modicum of support to the players. They could have had a chat on the issue, rather than make a catfight out of it. Clarke should know better to keep his players in check, not by this means though.

The players on their part should have a better understanding of their responsibilities and go with the flow. A rebel on an alien land would certainly tarnish the image of the board and as players they wouldn’t want to have that kind of dirt on their hands. The homework-gate controversy should be considered as a one-off incident and the team should work together to salvage some pride before they venture home